Jennifer Aniston's Blue Hill Restaurant Proposal: New Details!

Posted Wednesday August 15, 2012 3:05 PM GMT

Exciting new details of Jennifer Aniston's engagement to Justin Theroux are beginning to unravel, and many will be surprised to hear how casually he popped the question.

While celebrating Justin's 41st birthday in New York City on Friday (August 10), the "Wanderlust" co-stars crept down three steps below street level for dinner at Blue Hill where the NY Post says he got down on one knee.

After the "American Psycho" hunk proposed, the restaurant's rep told Page Six, “We are thrilled about the news of their engagement, but we cannot comment on any guests.”

Jennifer's rep confirmed the news on Sunday and Theroux's spokesperson released a statement explaining, “Justin had an amazing birthday on Friday, receiving an extraordinary gift when his girlfriend . . . accepted his proposal of marriage.”

Photo Credit: